This is my
second essay about J.D. Vance’s books. The first essay was entitled, What does Hillbilly Elegy tell us about J.D. Vance’s daimon? This essay is mainly about his
most recent book, Communion: Finding My Way Back to Faith.
The
question of how Vance would be likely to use the power of the presidency is of
interest to me – and to many others who do not live in the United States –
because it has potential to have a profound impact on the world in which we
live. People all over the world must adjust to the impact of choices made by
voters in the United States.
Prediction markets
suggest that the probability of Vance being elected president in 2028 is now
around 14% (Kalshi). The probability that he will be the Republican nominee is around
31% to 33%. The outcome of the recent U.S. mid-term elections has made it seem less
likely that Vance will become president, largely because there is now perceived
to be a higher probability that a Democrat will be elected. At this point we
don’t even know whether Vance will seek to be the Republican nominee or whether
the Democrats can nominate an electable candidate.
Vance seems to have provided an honest account of the
evolution of his religious beliefs in Communion. On politics, the book
avoids discussing the influence of post-liberals such as Adrian Vermeule and
Patrick Deneen, but the views he expresses appear to place him close to that
camp. They suggest a version of communitarianism, and I will argue that the main
question it raises is how far he would rely on top-down direction rather than
on spontaneous social change.
My essay on Hillbilly Elegy concluded that while that book tells
us a good deal about Vance’s values -
family, individual agency, self-reliance and hard work- it only offers a hint
of anything that could be called a supreme aim or guiding principle. That hint
appears in the final pages, where he introduces us to Brian, a kid from
Appalachian Kentucky who reminded J.D. of himself when he was fifteen years
old. I suggested that J.D’s concern for children like Brian hinted that his
daimon might be to give people like Brian a better chance in life.
My reading of Communion suggests
that Vance’s preoccupations are both narrower and broader than I had suggested
in my essay on Hillbilly Elegy. They are narrower because Communion
suggests that J.D.’s personal journey over the last decade has been strongly
motivated by a desire to be a good father to his own children. They are broader
because Vance, the politician, seems intent on waging a cultural war against “false
prophet economists” who use GDP statistics to “argue the American Dream is
healthy even as suicide and addiction rates soar and the laughter of children
fades from our streets”.
In this essay, I focus on four issues that may shed light on
the way Vance might use the powers of the presidency:
- The implications of attributing past ethical shortcomings to Ayn Rand’s philosophy;
- The question of whether principles that have governed international relations in the post-World War II era now have less validity because adherence to Christianity has declined in Europe;
- The ethical foundation of Vance’s approach to economics;
- Vance’s views about the role of government in cultural change.
A thread running through these issues is the one in the
Hayek epigraph: whether a good society is better pursued by directing it from
above or by allowing it to develop through the choices and interactions of free
individuals.
I have endeavoured to focus on what Vance has written in Communion,
but in some instances my interpretations and judgements may be influenced
by other sources.
Attribution for past ethical shortcomings
Vance tells us that while he was at Ohio State University “getting
drunk and acting like a jerk had filled the void left by God”. He acknowledges
that his attitudes had something in common with those of Tucker Max, a popular
figure at that time who blogged about his sexual and drinking exploits. Vance ends
the relevant chapter by telling us that he “increasingly began to feel” that he
was “not an especially good person”.
I think it is commendable for anyone telling their life story
to confess to their past shortcomings. It is often interesting to learn how
others have met ethical and other challenges and eventually redeemed
themselves. J.D.’s life story certainly has a redemption theme. A
characteristic of such redemption
themes is that the narrator eventually develops toward actualization of an
inner destiny.
The problem that I have with Vance’s confession is his apparent
attribution of personal shortcomings to the philosophy of Ayn Rand. I am not
an Objectivist and have no desire to spend the rest of my life defending Rand.
However, I can’t ignore the impression that Vance left me with that he was attributing
his boorish behaviour as a young man to his absorption of Rand’s philosophy.
Vance suggests that Rand’s philosophy “filled a void left by
the faith” he had discarded. A few pages later, he explains:
“My new life required a new philosophy, and like many young men on the political right, I had absorbed Ayn Rand’s hyper-individualism. I gave even love, the most selfless state of mind imaginable, a selfish Randian spin: Love is when we value another person so highly that it’s in our selfish interest to be nice to them. Conversely, when we no longer value someone, it’s fine to discard past affections.”
The main
problem I have with that passage is its failure to recognize that Rand’s use of
the word “selfish” is not the same as common usage of that word to describe opportunistic
behavior showing no regard for others. I have written about that previously:
“I can’t remember when I first became aware that Ayn Rand viewed selfishness as a virtue, and had written a book entitled The Virtue of Selfishness. During the 1990s, I was certainly aware that most of the small number of Australians who knew of Rand’s existence were of the opinion that she and her followers were ethically challenged and encouraged narcissism. That view was later expounded in a book by Anne Manne, which I commented upon here.
In a post on this blog in 2009 I asked myself: Did Ayn Rand regard selfishness as a virtue? I knew she did, but I pondered the question because the heroes of Atlas Shrugged did not seem to me to be selfish. I noted that Rand’s view that selfishness is a virtue followed from a narrow definition of selfishness as “concern with one’s own interests”, and speculated that Rand had used that definition to draw attention to her opposition to the view that self-sacrifice is a virtue.
A few months later, I wrote on the topic, How far can Ayn Rand’s ethical egoism be defended? That post was an attempt to summarize some of the views of participants in a Cato symposium on ‘What’s living and dead in Ayn Rand’s moral and political thought’. One of the aspects I focused on was the question of whether Rand, like Aristotle, viewed virtue – including regard for others - as a constitutive part of the agent’s own interest, or as an instrumental strategy for attaining that interest. Although the participants in the discussion were all scholars familiar with Rand’s writings, they were unable to agree on that point.”
Scholars differ in their understanding of some aspects of Rand’s
philosophy. One doesn’t need to know much about Objectivism, however, to
understand that getting drunk and acting like a jerk are not consistent with it.
Rand considered
that it was immoral for people to impair their cognitive faculties deliberately
through heavy drinking. Acting like a jerk contradicts her ideal of a
self-respecting individual. She would likely suggest that anyone who feels a lack
of self-respect should reflect on whether those feelings are warranted, for
example because they have breached standards of integrity that they have previously
chosen to live by.
Anyone who is aware that they have breached their own
standards should obviously take steps to modify their behaviour. I am glad that
Vance has apparently found a way to do that and have no comment to make on the
approach he has adopted.
However, the manner in which Vance has linked his recollections of Rand’s
philosophy to his own behaviour as a young man signals to me that, as president, he would be likely to
oppose the individualism advocated by classical liberals.
International relations
In 2024 Senator J.D. Vance was invited to attend the Munich
Security Conference. He tells us that he was invited “as a curiosity: a skeptic
of the foreign policy consensus of the previous half century”. Vance explained
his position thus:
“Whatever benefits had accrued, and whatever world wars had been avoided, the fruits of the so-called rules-based international order, especially since the mid-1990s, were rotten. And my original instinct was to throw this in everyone’s face: The fruits of your leadership are pointless wars of choice and declining life expectancy in your own country. Perhaps your life’s work was for naught.”
Some of what Vance writes about his position at the
Conference makes sense to me. The note of realism he injected about the limited
ability of the United States to assist in the defence of Ukraine rings true.
The U.S. “needed Europe to step up”; it “couldn’t unilaterally police any conflict
of its choosing”.
I begin to have problems with Vance’s position, however, when
he suggests that the decline in the extent to which political leaders refer to
God in their speeches in international forums such as the Munich Security
Conference has deep significance. He suggests that when NATO was being set up, Christianity
gave the NATO participants “a shared moral language”. Over the decades that
followed, however, the West “forgot what it stood for”:
“In the vacuum, we saw a new creed take form: a secular global liberalism that maintained the vocabulary of rights while shedding the religious foundation that gave them meaning.”
What are we to understand from that? When supporters of secular
global liberalism (or a rules-based international order) advocate policies to
discourage rape and pillage, why should that be less credible or meaningful than
when Christian nationalists advocate the same policies? Adherence to norms that
protect natural rights is not the exclusive preserve of Christian nationalists.
Since Vance is making his claims about the growth of secular
values in the context of a discussion of defense policy, perhaps he has in mind
that those values and rising economic prosperity have been accompanied by a
decline in the willingness of people to defend their country if war breaks out.
There is some evidence to support that view, but recent research has shown that
proximate conflicts also affect citizens’ willingness to fight. (See reference for
Sorg et al below).
Vance’s discussion of international relations suggests to me that it is appropriate to label him as a Christian nationalist. He certainly blends nationalist sentiments with his Roman Catholic beliefs. It seems likely that a distinctive blend of Christianity and nationalism would tend to play a larger role in the foreign policy of the United States if he became president.
However, it is difficult to specify what that might entail. For
example, is Vance’s understanding of Christianity consistent with the
isolationist policies some commentators suggest that he espouses, or does it
entail closer relations between the United States and countries with high rates
of Christian church attendance? Since Pew
data indicates that rates of church attendance are substantially higher in
Mexico than in the U.S., perhaps it means that the U.S. would be likely to seek
closer relations with Mexico under a Vance presidency. Who knows? A Christian nationalist foreign policy could entail
any objective that Vance can somehow portray to be consistent with Christianity
and the interests of the United States.
Economics
Vance has a low opinion of economics as a profession and
considers that economic considerations play too great a role in background
debates on policy issues.
One of Vance’s sources of economic inspiration is Oren Cass,
who writes extensively about economic issues. After referencing a book written
by Cass, Vance writes:
“In that book, Oren argues that “economic piety” has taken over American public life. In particular, he argues that an obsession with maximizing consumption has focused our policy, and indeed our entire culture, on a potentially harmful metric.”
The point Cass and Vance are attempting to make is that a
focus on consumption fails to account for people as anything besides consumers
and thus undervalues other ways of measuring a good life. Vance is particularly
concerned that we should recognize that a job isn’t just a source of income: it
“allows people to feel accomplished and provides community”.
One issue this raises is whether the conceptual apparatus of
economics can incorporate aspects of the good life that are not encompassed by consumption
(more precisely, the consumer goods that money can buy). It is not difficult to show that those aspects
of the good life can be incorporated even under the restrictive utility
maximizing assumptions of conventional neoclassical economics. I discussed
relevant economic issues in 2008 in a post entitled: “Are
libertarians baffled by down-shifters?”
It seems to me that there is nothing unusual about people
taking non-pecuniary factors into consideration in making work choices. Among
people I know, some seem to me to place too little emphasis on non-pecuniary factors,
and some place too much emphasis on such factors. In either case, however, it
is appropriate that they should make their own choices and live with the
consequences.
Cass (and Vance) raise another issue that has more
substance. That is whether policymakers give too much attention to national
statistics of consumption and GDP. Vance
is not the first politician to draw attention to this issue. In 1968, Robert F
Kennedy concluded a critique of GNP (a concept closely related to GDP) by saying
that the metric “measures everything, in short, except that which makes life
worthwhile”.
In making the point that trying to maximize GDP makes no
moral sense, Vance suggests:
“A Christian approach to economics would demand something different; concern for GDP, yes, but only insofar as it promotes human flourishing.”
I agree with that assertion - even though it remains true if
one substitutes ‘secular humanist’ for ‘Christian’.
However, when one attempts to specify the goods of a
flourishing human, it is notable that the countries in which persons chosen at
random have likely been most successful in attaining those goods have
relatively high levels of economic and personal freedom and relatively high per
capita GDP levels. In discussing determinants of opportunities to obtain basic
goods in Freedom, Progress, and Human Flourishing, I concluded:
“High incomes appear to be the most pervasive element, but liberty and a culture of trust have played an important role in facilitating the underlying economic development process which has enabled incomes to rise.”
The list of basic goods of a flourishing human that I suggested
in my book was as follows:
- Wise and well-informed self-direction.
- Health and longevity.
- Positive relationships.
- Living in harmony with nature.
- Psychological well-being.
In the process of arriving at that list, I suggested that any
attempt to identify the basic goods must remain a matter for ongoing reflection
and discussion. Some have suggested that spirituality should be added to that
list. Teodora Ciobanu has provided an interesting discussion of that in her
chapter of the recently published book, From Politics to Morality: Implications
of Rasmussen and Den Uyl’s Norms of Liberty. She
suggests that it is possible for religion to become a unifying purpose in one’s
life “without diminishing in any sense the natural dimension of one’s existence
and the other basic goods worth pursuing”.
As might be expected, Communion contains paragraphs
that support the economic nationalism of the Trump administration. However, Vance
also hints at a possible policy agenda directed toward encouraging young people
to have children:
“Our young people may differ in some ways from those in Korea or Japan, but all of them are responding to the economic and cultural incentives: work more, consume more, achieve more. Suppress the biological urge to fall in love and have babies. Sacrifice family for your cubicle. We—across political movements and countries—have done this to ourselves. And it is no coincidence that we embraced this hypereconomic logic at the very moment our civilization moved away from Christianity.”
The role of government
Vance’s view of the role of government seems to be strongly
influenced by Rerum Novarum, the 1891 encyclical by Pope Leo XIII
addressing the rights and duties of workers, employers, and the state. Leo XIII
held that because people are fundamentally social, their mediating institutions
such as unions and churches ought to be prioritized. According to Vance, “Pope
Leo XIII’s theory of human nature strikes a balance so perfect it seems
divinely inspired”. Vance likes Leo XIII’s emphasis on duty and family and his rejection
of libertarian and liberal views of culture.
Vance refers to subsidiarity:
“This idea that we all exist within particular spheres of family, community, and on and on, building up to a nation, is called subsidiarity. And it recognizes that each sphere of life depends on the others. It is very hard to be a good family man unless you have a decent wage and have support from friends, community, and church. And it’s tough for those institutions to thrive without a functional political system.”
When I look up subsidiarity, however, the definition of that
word has a more specific emphasis on social and political issues being handled by
the smallest, lowest, or least centralized competent authority.
The principle of subsidiarity seems to me to be consistent
with classical liberalism. There are loopholes, however, which may enable a
president to exercise excessive power while pretending to endorse subsidiarity.
Governments can often define a phenomenon as a social problem and to decide which
authorities are competent to deal with it.
The issue of whether low birth rates pose a problem that warrants
government intervention is an example of potential misuse of subsidiarity. If we
begin with the proposition that each woman of child-bearing age is a competent
authority to decide how many children she should have, it seems to me that the
onus is on those who want higher birth rates to argue the case transparently. The
paragraph from Vance’s book quoted at the end of the previous section asserts
that something has suppressed the biological urge to fall in love and have
babies. However, it doesn’t tell us why we should be concerned about the
individual choices that have produced that outcome.
When we come to consider what could or should be done to raise
birth rates, we are confronted by ethical questions. From what I have read on
the subject, raising birth rates would require a cultural change that could not
be achieved with minor adjustments to existing policy measures to support
families. A president who wanted to achieve substantial change would need to
contemplate major changes in taxation and expenditure to address financial
security issues that currently discourage many people from cohabiting and having
babies. The provision of the required financial incentives raises the issue of
why those who choose to remain childless or to have small families should be
required to subsidize those who choose to have large families.
In Hillbilly Elegy, Vance suggested that while public
policy could help with cultural problems, “there is no government that can fix
these problems for us”. His view may now have changed but it is not clear how
far he would be willing to go in proposing changes in economic incentives to
arrest the decline in birth rates.
A more fundamental issue raised by Vance’s attribution of
low birth rates to a “work more, consume more, achieve more” culture is that it
seems to stem from a view of culture as something imposed on individuals,
rather than an outcome of individual choices and interactions. He seems to associate
the classical liberal view of culture with atomistic individualism where humans
are viewed as isolated economic units.
F.A. Hayek actively rejected this caricature. In his famous
essay, Individualism: True and False, Hayek explicitly argued
that "true individualism" is inherently social, relying on the
organic, spontaneous networks of family, friends and local communities.
The sentence
from Hayek’s essay quoted in the epigraph draws attention to the potential for society
to be diminished when individual minds seek to control or direct it. Attempts
to impose order from above impact adversely on the spontaneous forces of social
change. If a substantial number of women are unable to have as many babies as
they would like that may itself tend to bring about corrective cultural change.
As birth rates decline, people who aspire to become grandparents have an added incentive
to help their children attain the financial security necessary to support
families. That is less likely to happen if family support is seen to be a
government responsibility.
More generally, if people in a free society perceive the emergence
of a cultural problem, there are strong reasons to expect them to respond
spontaneously in ways that will alleviate it. By contrast, top-down
interventions often make families and communities dependent on ongoing government
support, including tariffs and other measures to support employment in uncompetitive
industries and occupations.
Conclusion
In this essay I have asked what J.D. Vance’s latest book
suggests about how he would be likely to use the powers of the presidency of
the United States. A memoir of faith is limited evidence for that question, and
my conclusions are tentative.
Vance’s account of his time at Ohio State left me with the
impression that he attributes his boorish behaviour to Rand’s philosophy. I
think that is a misreading of Rand, and I suspect it reflects a broader
tendency to see classical liberal individualism as a corrosive force. Whether
that would shape his approach as president is unclear.
On international relations, Vance makes some points I find
persuasive, such as the limits on US capacity to police conflicts of its
choosing. However, he appears to blend nationalist sentiment with his Catholic
faith. It is hard to say what that blend would entail in practice, and the
United States may well move further from the rules-based order.
On economics, I agree with Vance that GDP matters only
insofar as it promotes flourishing. My concern is that high incomes, economic
freedom and trust have been the most pervasive foundations of the basic goods,
so economic nationalism could trade away the very conditions for flourishing.
His hints about encouraging young people to have children raise the question of
how far he would go in changing economic incentives.
On the role of government, Vance endorses subsidiarity,
which is consistent with classical liberalism. The risk I see is that the
principle gives a president latitude to define which problems are cultural and
which authorities are competent to address them. His remark in Hillbilly
Elegy that no government can fix these problems for us suggests some
restraint, but Communion does not tell us whether he still holds that
view.
If Hayek is right, the cultural problems Vance diagnoses are
more likely to be corrected by free individuals responding to them than by
direction from above. What he proposes in respect of birth-rate policy would be
an early test of which view he holds.
References
Bates, Winton Russell, Freedom, Progress, and Human
Flourishing (Hamilton Books, 2021).
Ciobanu, Teodora, “Is Norms of Liberty Compatible with
Religion” in From Politics to Morality: Implications of Rasmussen and DenUyl’s Norms of Liberty, ed. Edward W. Younkins (Bloomsbury: 2026).
Hayek,
F.A., “Individualism: True and False”, republished as Chapter 7 in Chiaki
Nishiyama and Kurt R. Leube, The Essence of Hayek, Hoover Institution
Press, 1984.
Sorg, Alexander, Wolfgang Wagner and Michal Onderco, ‘Fighting
for their country: How proximate conflict shapes citizens’ attitudes’, European
Journal of International Security (2025).
Vance,
J.D., Communion: Finding My Way Back to Faith (Harper Collins, 2026).
Vance,
J.D., Hillbilly Elegy (Harper Collins, 2016).

No comments:
Post a Comment